The House Committee on the Judiciary will hear proposed bills on reproductive health tomorrow night. The LWVRI, Planned Parenthood, NOW, the Woman Project, the ACLU and other members of the Coalition for Reproductive Freedom, support 5127, The Reproductive Health Care Act, the only bill that will codify Roe v Wade in RI law and remove restrictive and outdated laws from current RI law. It is important to come and bring your LWVRI pins and signs to support H 5127. There is a competing bill, 5125, called the Reproductive Privacy Act, which purports to protect Roe v Wade but in fact weakens its protections. See the analysis by the ACLU below.
Several other bills restricting abortion will be heard as well. THOSE WHO SUPPORT SAFE AND LEGAL ABORTION NEED TO SHOW UP.
H 5127 Reproductive Health Care Act compared with H 5125, Reproductive Privacy Act.
• The only goal of the RHCA is to establish reproductive choice as a right under Rhode Island law in accordance with Roe v. Wade. The RHCA was written to accomplish this goal in two main ways: (1) affirmatively codify the rights established in Roe v. Wade as a right under state law and (2) repeal all state statutes that are unconstitutional under Roe that remain in the R.I. General Laws. However, H-5125, the “Reproductive Privacy Act,” fails to accomplish that fundamental goal.
• Contrary to the RHCA and its basic goal, H-5125 preserves two anti-choice measures previously recognized as unconstitutional: explicitly preserving a revised version of the state’s criminal “quick child” law and implicitly preserving the state’s “Partial Birth Abortion” Act.
• As to the “quick child” law, the RHCA repeals that statute, while H-5125 revises it. Revising the language, instead of repealing it, amounts to a back-door effort to use the bill as a vehicle for “fetal homicide” legislation, which specifically, and problematically, treats a fetus as a person. Such a provision simply has no place in a bill purporting to preserve reproductive freedom.
• In addition, the “quick child” language has not been enforced because of its constitutional problems, yet is given new support by H-5125. Its inclusion would only create ambiguities about the bill’s meaning and applicability.
• Unlike the RHCA, H-5125 also fails to repeal the state’s “partial birth abortion” law, which was definitively declared unconstitutional in 1999. By repealing every other state abortion law that was struck down by the courts and leaving this particular one on the books, H-5125 reinforces legislative support of this unconstitutional law. This is particularly concerning since, unlike the federal law ban that remains applicable in Rhode Island, the state law that H-5125 fails to repeal banned the most common medical procedure used in second-trimester abortions. Although we do not believe unconstitutional laws like this one can be resurrected should the U.S. Supreme Court undermine or reverse Roe, their full repeal was designed to prevent that argument from even being considered.
• H-5125 contains new language requiring compliance with “all applicable federal and state law,” which are not specified. This language could support attacks on reproductive rights by virtue of its open-ended ambiguity. Right now, mandatory federal law — not the law of Rhode Island — preserves reproductive rights. If that changes, new federal restrictions — currently unknown — may be interpreted as mandatory by this vague language, and current state laws could be misapplied to interfere with reproductive rights.
The Reproductive Privacy Act should either be amended to mirror the RHCA, or else rejected in favor of the RHCA, which is the only bill that truly meets the goal of codifying Roe into state law.
(401) 831-7171 | ACLU of RHODE ISLAND | riaclu.org
Monday, January 28, 2019
Saturday, January 19, 2019
Rally at the State House on Wednesday, January 23, to show support for Reproductive Freedom in Rhode Island
The League is part of the Coalition for Reproductive Freedom which is holding a rally at the State House on Wednesday, January 23.
JAN. 23, 2019 RHCA Celebration at the State House
Reproductive Health Care Act - Step 1 victory
Thank you, All, who contacted Gov. Raimondo, urging her to include in her State of the State address passage of the Reproductive Health Care Act (RHCA) this year as one of her priorities. She did so, and that message drew huge applause from a majority of legislators and visitors alike.!!!!
This is one early victory for us....but..next step... We need as many of you as possible to pack the State House "Roe-tunda" next Wednesday, January 23, at 3:00 p.m for the celebratory roll-out of this year's bills, with speakers, press coverage, etc. Bring your friends. (This will come a day after the annual Right To Life gathering, and as a visual we need to have at least as large a crowd.) The House bill is H-5127, introduced by Rep. Edith Ajello, and 38 co-sponsors. The Senate version, introduced by Sen. Gayle Goldin, is S-2163, with 17 co-sponsors.
You can seek out your legislators afterwards to voice your support for the bill; thank those who have signed on; and urge them to lean on the Leadership for a floor vote and passage this year. Or if they oppose, let them know passage is important to you, 71% of Rhode Islanders polled this year, and 61% of Catholics in Rhode Island.
To find out who your legislator is go to: www.sec.state.ri.us/elections/findyourofficials.
To find who are co-sponsors go to: State of Rhode Island General Assembly, Press Releases 1/15/2019 "Goldin, Ajello file Reproductive Health Care Act."
Before the bells that announce the beginning of a session you can enter either chamber. Sessions usually start around 4:00 p.m., when visitors leave the chamber, but may view the legislative session from the 3rd floor galleries.
Parking. You can park at the Mall for 2 hrs for free. It's about an 8 min. walk to the entry of the State House on Smith St. Otherwise there are parking meters around the State House for up to 2 hrs.and take quarters and credit cards. Carpooling is always a good option.
If you can't attend, please telephone your representative/senator to thank them for co-sponsoring/and or e-mail them.
Hoping to see as many of you as possible next Wednesday!
Mary Chace - League of Women Voters, RI Coalition for Reproductive Freedom
Wednesday, January 2, 2019
Call your Representative tomorrow to ask him to support HR 1, which contains essential reforms of the voting process
Tomorrow, members of the 116th Congress will be sworn in and begin their work to represent their constituents. At the League, we are excited about the new session of Congress and we are proud to support a new piece of legislation--HR1: For the People Act-- which stands to improve American elections by making our elections more free, fair, and accessible to all eligible Americans.
Welcome your Representative to Washington, DC, with a call to support a new sweeping democracy reform bill that will make elections fairer and put the power back in the hands of the American people.
HR1 includes comprehensive reforms, like restoring the Voting Rights Act, improving Automatic Voter Registration, creating a public financing system through small donor matching funds, overturning Citizens United, ending partisan gerrymandering, and more! This bill will make our elections fairer and put the power back into the hands of the American people and it deserves bipartisan support.
Voters sent a clear message in the 2018 elections that they are ready for bold, comprehensive democracy reforms. Now we must continue to demand change by speaking out. Call your Representative today and ask them to vote Yes for HR1